Kelsie graduated from Houghton College in 2017 with a Bachelor of Science in Communication and a minor in Education.
While at Houghton,the Landisville, PA native was a member of the field hockey and women's lacrosse teams. Throughout her career, she started all 65 games she played, tallying totals of 17 goals, 22 assists, and 11 defensive saves. As a senior, she finished second in the Empire 8 in Assists per game with 0.563. In addition, she earned two All-Conference selections.
In the classroom, Kelsie was a three-time member of the NFHCA Division III National Academic Squad and appeared on the Empire 8 President's List three times.