2016-17
Cory McCarty, men's outdoor track & field (800 meter run, third place)
Gwen Stokes, women's indoor track & field (high jump, third place)
Nikki Garns, women's soccer (3rd team)
Alexis Lamb, women's soccer (3rd team)
Jacob Dunnett, men's soccer (3rd team)

2015-16
Joanna Friesen, women’s outdoor track & field (3000 meter steeplechase, third place)
Joanna Friesen, women's indoor track & field (4x800 meter relay, second place)
Kate Taggart, women's indoor track & field (4x800 meter relay, second place)
Rebekah White, women's indoor track & fieldk (4x800 meter relay, second place)
Nikki Garns, women's indoor track & field (4x800 meter, second place)
Sarah Gabriele, women’s soccer (1st team)
Alexis Lamb, women’s soccer (1st team)
Jessica Beattie, women’s soccer (2nd team)
Jesse Toth, men’s soccer (2nd team)

2014-15
Stephany Ellison, women's soccer (1st team)
Alexis Lamb, women's soccer (1st team)
Maisie Pipher, women's basketball (2nd team)
Laurel Wroblicky, volleyball (2nd team)
Andrea Melhorn, women's outdoor track & field (hammer throw, second place)
Jesse Toth, men's soccer (2nd team)
Seth Cornell, baseball (2nd team)
Jared Toth, men's soccer (3rd team)
Sarah Gabriele, women's soccer (3rd team)
Joanna Friesen, women's outdoor track & field (3000 meter steeplechase, third place)
Johnathan Stowe, men's basketball (Honorable Mention)

2013-14
David Richards, men’s outdoor track & field (10,000 meter champion)
David Richards, men’s cross country 
Alyssa Figueroa, women's indoor track & field (triple jump, third place)
Jared Toth, men’s soccer (1^st team)
Kristen Moose, women’s basketball (1^st team)
Stephany Ellison, women’s soccer (2^nd team)
Alyssa Figueroa, women’s soccer (2^nd team)
Paul Seddon, men’s soccer (3^rd team)
Jacob Dunnett, men’s soccer (Honorable Mention)
 
2012-13
Alyssa Figueroa, women’s soccer (2^nd team)
Stephany Ellison, women’s soccer (2^nd team)
Michael Dix, men’s soccer (2^nd team)
Kristen Moose, women’s basketball (2^nd team)
Jared Toth, men’s soccer (3^rd team)
 
2011-12
Keeler Topping, women’s soccer (2^nd team)
Jennifer Hudson, women’s soccer (2^nd team)
David Richards, outdoor track & field (10,000m run, third place)
Alyssa Figueroa, outdoor track & field (100 meter run, second place)
Alyssa Figueroa, outdoor track & field (triple jump, third place)
Alyssa Figueroa, indoor track & field (55 meter dash champion)
Danielle Brenon, outdoor track & field (10,000 meter champion; outstanding performer)
Danielle Brenon, outdoor track & field (5,000 meter champion)
Michael Amico, men’s soccer (Honorable Mention)
 
1989-90
Dan Meade, men’s soccer (2^nd team)
Marion Austin, outdoor track and field (10,000 meter champion; outstanding performer)
Marion Austin, outdoor track and field  (5,000 meter champion)
 
1988-89
Jacki Carlson, women’s basketball (1^st team)
Judy Fox, volleyball

1987-88
Brian Thompson, men’s soccer (1^st team)
Tim Kangas, men’s soccer (2^nd team)
Judy Fox, volleyball (1st team)
 
1985-86
Jodi Carlson, women’s basketball (1^st team)

1984-85
Jeff Anspach, men’s basketball (2^nd team)
Greg Gidman, men's soccer (1st team)
Dave Ortlip, men's soccer (1st team)
Mary McCullough, women's track and field (at-large)
 
1982-83
Dan Ortlip, men’s soccer (1^st team)
Bill Baker, men’s soccer (HM)
David Landry, outdoor track and field (3000 meter steeplechase champion)
David Acree, men’s basketball (2^nd team)
Ken Jones, men’s basketball (Honorable Mention)
 
1980-81
Peter Fuller, men’s soccer (2^nd team)
Kevin Austin, men’s soccer
 
1979-80
Steve Burke, men’s soccer (1^st team)
Peter Fuller, men’s soccer (2^nd team)