2025-26
Women's Basketball (NCCAA)
Amos Bixler, men's cross country (NCAA)

2024-25
Women's Basketball (NCCAA)
Alexa Belanger, women's indoor track and field (NCAA)
Alexa Belanger, women's outdoor track and field (NCAA)
Victoria Brewster, women's indoor track and field (NCAA)
Noelle Linenfelser, women's cross country (NCAA)

2024-25
Men's Basketball (NCCAA)

2023-24
Men's Tennis (NCAA)

2022-23
Women's Basketball (NCCAA)

2022-23
Men's Tennis (NCAA)

2020-21
Men's Tennis (NCAA)

2016-2017
Men's Soccer (NCCAA)
Women's Soccer (NCCAA)
Men's Indoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)

2015-16
Women's Soccer (NCCAA National Champions)
Women's Cross Country (NCCAA)
Men's Cross Country (NCCAA)
Men's Indoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)

2014-15
Women's Soccer (NCCAA)
Women's Volleyball (NCCAA)
Women's Cross Country (NCCAA)
Men's Cross Country (NCCAA)*
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Men's Indoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)

2013-14
Women's Soccer (NCCAA)
Men's Soccer (NCCAA)
Women's Cross Country (NCCAA)
Men's Cross Country (NCCAA)
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Men's Indoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
 
2012-13
Women's Soccer (NCCAA)
Women's Cross Country (NCCAA)
Men's Cross Country (NCCAA)
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Men's Indoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)

 2011-12
Women's Soccer (NAIA)
Women's Cross Country (NCCAA)
Men's Cross Country (NCCAA)
Women's Cross Country (NAIA)*
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)*
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Men's Indoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)

2010-11
Women's Soccer (NAIA)
Women's Cross Country (NAIA)*
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)*
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)

2009-10
Women's Soccer (NAIA)
Women's Cross Country (NAIA)*
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA) 

2008-09
Women's Soccer (NAIA)
Women's Cross Country (NAIA)*
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)*
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Men's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)

2007-08
Women's Soccer (NAIA)
Women's Cross Country (NAIA)*
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)*
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Men's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)

2006-07
Women's Soccer (NAIA)
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)*
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Men's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)
 
2005-06
Women's Soccer (NAIA)
Men's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)
 
2004-05
Women's Soccer (NAIA)
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Men's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)
 
2003-04
Women's Soccer (NAIA)
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)*
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Men's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)

2002-03
Women's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Men's Indoor Track & Field (NAIA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NAIA)

2001-02
Women's Soccer (NAIA)
 
2000-01
Women's Volleyball (NAIA)
Women's Basketball (NAIA)
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)
Women's Cross Country (NAIA)
 
1999-2000
Women's Soccer (NAIA)
Women's Basketball (NAIA)
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)
Women's Cross Country (NAIA)
 
1998-99
Women's Volleyball (NAIA)
Women's Soccer (NAIA)
Women's Basketball (NAIA)
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)
Women's Cross Country (NAIA)
 
1997-98
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)
Women's Cross Country (NAIA)
 
1996-97
Men's Soccer (NAIA)
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)
Women's Cross Country (NAIA)
 
1995-96
Men's Soccer (NAIA)
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)
Women's Cross Country (NAIA)
 
1994-95
Men's Soccer (NAIA)
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)
Women's Cross Country (NAIA)
 
1993-94
Women's Basketball (NAIA)
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)
Women's Cross Country (NAIA)
 
1992-93
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)
Women's Cross Country (NAIA)
 
1991-92
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)
 
1990-91
Men's Cross Country (NAIA)

1989-90
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
Women's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)
 
1988-89
Women's Volleyball (NCCAA)
Men's Soccer (NAIA)
Women's Basketball (NCCAA)
Men's Outdoor Track & Field (NCCAA)

1987-88
Women's Basketball (NCCAA)
 
1986-87
Women's Volleyball (NCCAA)
Men's Soccer (NCCAA National Champions)
Women's Cross Country (NCCAA)
Men's Cross Country (NCCAA)
 
1985-86
Women's Volleyball (NCCAA)
Women's Soccer (NAIA)
 
1984-85
Women's Volleyball (NCCAA)
 
1983-84
Women's Volleyball (NCCAA)

1982-83
Men's Basketball (NCCAA)
Men's Outdoor Track & field (NCCAA)
 
1980-81
Men's Soccer (NCCAA National Champions)
 
1979-80
Men's Soccer (NCCAA National Champions)
 
1976-77
Men's Soccer (NAIA)
 
1975-76
Men's Soccer (NAIA)
 
 *Individual Qualifiers