2016-17
Jesse Toth, men's soccer (Empire 8 Male Senior Scholar-Athlete)
Jesse Toth, men's soccer (NCCAA Midwest Region Player)

2015-16
Andrew Bussey, men's soccer (Empire 8 Rookie of the Year)

2014-15
Stephany Ellison, women's soccer (Empire 8 Offensive Player)
Stephany Ellison, women's soccer (NCCAA East Region Co-Player)
Laurel Wroblicky, volleyball (Empire 8 Defensive Player)
Nikki Garns, women's indoor track and field (Empire 8 Rookie of the Year)

2013-14
Jared Toth, men’s soccer (NCCAA East Region)
Stephany Ellison, women’s soccer (NCCAA East Region)
Stephany Ellison, women's soccer (Empire 8 Offensive Player)
Kristen Moose, women’s basketball (NCCAA East Region)
Joanna Friesen, women's outdoor track and field (Empire 8 Rookie of the Year)
 
2012-13
Stephany Ellison, women’s soccer (NCCAA East Region)
 
2011-12
Keeler Topping, women’s soccer (NCCAA East Region)
Kristen Moose, women’s basketball (American Mideast Conference)
 
2009-10
Keeler Topping, women’s soccer (American Mideast Conference)
 
2008-09
Bethany Kowalczyk, women’s soccer (American Mideast Conference)
 
2007-08
Hannah Swift, women’s soccer (American Mideast Conference)
Hannah Swift, women’s soccer (NAIA Region IX)
 
2006-07
Bethany Kowalczyk, women’s soccer (American Mideast Conference)
Bethany Kowalczyk, women’s soccer (NAIA Region IX)
 
2005-06
Bethany Kowalczyk, women’s soccer (American Mideast Conference)
Bethany Kowalczyk, women’s soccer (NAIA Region IX)
 
2004-05
Bethany Kowalczyk, women’s soccer (American Mideast Conference)
Bethany Kowalczyk, women’s soccer (NAIA Region IX)
 
2003-04
Trevor Eby, men’s soccer (American Mideast Conference)
Kirsten Nelson, volleyball (American Mideast Conference)
JoAnna Beardsley, women’s soccer (American Mideast Conference)
JoAnna Beardsley, women’s soccer (NAIA Region IX)
 
2002-03
Kirsten Nelson, volleyball (American Mideast Conference)
JoAnna Beardsley, women’s soccer (American Mideast Conference)
Hannah Toth, women’s soccer (NAIA Region IX)
 
2000-01
Heather Mann, women’s soccer (conference)
 
1999-2000
Andrea Potteiger, women’s soccer (conference)
Andrea Potteiger, women’s soccer (NAIA Region IX)
 
1998-99
Heather Shear, women’s soccer (conference)
Sunshine Leonard, women’s soccer (NAIA Region IX)
 
1997-98
Akim Antwi, men’s soccer (Keystone Empire Collegiate Conference)
 
1993-94
Jamie Wellington, men’s soccer (NAIA District 18)
Dan Dominguez, men’s soccer (NAIA District 18)
 
1992-93
Randy Levak, men’s soccer (NAIA District 18)